All their gods and goddesses could not save the Athenians. In the circumstances, the Athenians did what many attacked by strong viruses do — they died. How do we know? Hear science writer Constance Holden's summary, giving an important fact, stating alternative hypotheses that are possible explanations of the important fact and, finally, circumstantial evidence that supports one of the hypotheses:
According to estimates based on the writings of historian-general Thucydides, up to 300,000 Athenians — one in every three — were felled during a Spartan siege by a mystery disease whose symptoms included high fevers, blistered skin, bilious vomiting, intestinal ulcerations, and diarrhea. Most victims died about a week after onset. Over the years, people have postulated causes [made hypotheses] ranging from bubonic plague to measles to a combination of influenza and staphylococci — but none seemed to fit.
But in a letter in the April-June [1996] journal Emerging Infectious Diseases, Patrick E. Olson, an epidemiologist at the Naval Medical Center in San Diego, and his colleagues propose that Ebola virus may be the culprit, . . . [noting that] in both the ancient and modern cases, victims died quickly, and both diseases appeared and vanished suddenly. In Athens there were widespread deaths among caregivers, but few among the attacking Spartans. This pattern suggested that the disease, like most strains of Ebola, was spread by personal contact and not by airborne pathogens. But what really got Olson’s pulse racing were the reports of ‘hiccupping’ among 15 percent of the Zaire Ebola patients — an unusual symptom also noted by Thucydides, himself a plague survivor.
There are some other tantalizing hints: Santorini Island near Athens is the site of a Minoan fresco featuring green monkeys, a species known to harbor Ebola. And because Athens was a major port, the virus could easily have been spread by sailors from ships that traded with Africa.
Epidemiologist Karl M. Johnson . . . says that the interpretation proposed by Olson is definitely ‘suggestive. . . . You’d have to say it’s at least as likely as any of the other ones proposed.’ Proving it is going to be difficult, however. The Greeks cremated their dead, along with any genetic evidence from the Ebola virus.
(“Ebola: Ancient history of “new” disease?” by Constance Holden. 1996. Science 272:1591. Quoted from page 76 of Best Research Practices, by H. Charles Romesburg. Lulu Enterprises, 2009.)
For bibliographic information about Constance Holden, click here.
Recent Comments